From two stars to three: what changes
Page 11 of How to Solve Star Battle Puzzles.
Three-star puzzles are the last step in this guide. They use a 14×14 board. The rules change in one way:
- Every row, every column and every region holds three stars. A 14×14 board holds 42 stars.
- No two stars touch, not even at a corner. That has not changed.
All the moves for one star and two stars still work. You count to three. The bigger board and the bigger regions also make some moves much more common. This page shows what changes, on real 14×14 three-star puzzles from the app.
What changes: the counts go to three
Region inside a line
Look at row 2. One region is five squares long, from column 7 to column 11, and all of it is in row 2. That region needs three stars, and row 2 needs three stars. So the region holds all the stars of row 2, and the Region inside a line move rules out the rest of the row.
Region inside a line: All the open squares of one region are in this row. So the stars left in this row must all be in that region. Rule out the rest of this row.
The rule from two stars still applies: rule out the rest of the line only when the region's stars left are the same as the line's stars left. Later in the same puzzle, another region has all its open squares in one row, but the counts are not the same.
The region's last star must go in row 8. But row 8 needs three stars, and this region gives it only one. So the rest of row 8 stays open. With three stars, a region can hold one, two or all three of a line's stars. Count both before you place a dot.
Last squares and Finished
The Last squares move counts the stars left, as before. Now a row can hold two stars and still need a third.
Last squares: This row has one open square and one star left. That square must be a star.
In the same way, the Finished move waits for the third star. A row with two stars is not finished. Only the squares around its stars are ruled out.
What changes: Tight squeeze
The Tight squeeze move counts side-by-side open squares. A group of side-by-side squares holds at most half its squares, rounded up. With three stars, two groups matter more than before:
- A group of 5 holds at most three stars: in its first, third and fifth squares. A line that needs three stars and has one group of 5 open squares puts its stars there.
- A group of 3 holds at most two stars: one at each end. A line that needs two stars and has one group of 3 puts them at the ends.
Hint 1 left row 2 with five open squares side by side, and row 2 needs three stars.
Tight squeeze: Open squares: 5. Stars left: 3. The open squares of this row form one group, side by side. Stars cannot sit side by side. So the stars go in every other square, from the first.
The group of 3 comes later in the same puzzle.
Tight squeeze: Open squares: 3. Stars left: 2. The open squares of this column form one group, side by side. Stars cannot sit side by side. So the stars go in every other square, from the first.
A line with one group of 5 open squares and three stars left comes up in 33% of the app's 14×14 three-star puzzles. A line with one group of 3 and two stars left comes up in 85%.
The Squeezed pair move also grows. A group of 6 is three pairs. When a line needs three stars and its open squares are three pairs, each pair holds one star.
What changes: 2×2 blocks across two rows
The 2×2 blocks move on one region works just as it does with two stars. The form for two rows changes. Two rows of 14 squares make seven 2×2 blocks side by side, and the two rows need six stars. Seven blocks for six stars leaves one block spare, so the count proves nothing. The move works only when the open squares of both rows fit in six blocks. That happens when some columns have no open square in either row.
2×2 blocks: The open squares of these two rows fit in 2×2 blocks, one block for each of their stars left. So each block holds one star. This square is the only open square of these rows in its block. It must be a star.
This form is rare. The app's hints use it, on two rows or two columns, in 13 of the 3,529 14×14 three-star puzzles. The one-region form is common, as the next section shows.
Moves that come up more often
A 14×14 board has 196 squares in 14 regions, so a region has 14 squares on average. Three stars can fit in such a region in many ways. So the moves that try the ways a region fits come up much more often. The numbers are the share of the app's 14×14 three-star puzzles whose hints use the move at least once, with 10×10 two-star puzzles in brackets.
- The Only one fit move: 97% (60%).
- The Every option agrees move: 98% on a region with two or three ways to fit (83%). The bigger case, where you test one square, comes up in 55% (53%). It is common, but no more common than with two stars.
- The 2×2 blocks move on one region: 88% (60%).
- The Region inside a line move in its harder form, where every way that a region fits puts its stars left in one line: 88% with two or three ways (66%), and 50% with four or more (23%).
Some moves come up less often. The Line inside a region move drops to 17% (45%), the Regions inside lines move to 15% (34%) and the Sub-regions move to 9 puzzles of 3,529.
The moves a three-star solver needs most
The number after each move is the share of the app's 14×14 three-star puzzles whose hints use the move at least once. Learn the moves near the top first.
- The Squeezed pair move: 99.7%.
- The Tight squeeze move: 90% with one group, and 98% with several groups.
- The Every option agrees move: 98% with two or three ways, and 55% with four or more.
- The Only one fit move: 97%.
- The 2×2 blocks move: 88%.
- The Region inside a line move: 76% in the form where all the open squares of a region are in one line.
To see these moves work together, follow a complete 14×14 three-star solve from the first hint to the last. If a puzzle stops, When you're stuck lists the moves in the order to try them.
Practice on puzzles like these in our Star Battle Puzzles app, for iPhone, iPad, Mac and Android.
Next: A 14×14 solve
Previous: Sub-regions
All parts of the guide